EA modelling finds wetlands, buffer strips and cover crops cut river nutrients by 5–22%
Environment Agency modelling of the Eden and upper Thames suggests combined farm-scale nature-based measures could cut river nitrogen and phosphorus, but climate change is likely to reduce their effectiveness.
By The Water Wire · Edited by David Bain

Nature-based solutions on farmland could reduce nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in rivers. However, their effect varies widely by catchment and season, and climate change is likely to weaken it. That is the finding of Environment Agency (EA) modelling published on GOV.UK on 9 November (Environment Agency).
What we know
The EA Chief Scientist's Group research (project SC250008) used the CSF-HYPE hydrological model. It tested three measures in two predominantly rural catchments, the Eden and the upper Thames:
- in-field wetlands
- buffer strips
- cover crops
The model covered the recent past (2000–2019) and two future periods (2020–2040 and 2060–2080). The future periods used UKCP18 projections under a high-emissions scenario.
The EA reported these results for the combined measures over the recent past:
- Upper Thames: total phosphorus fell by 5% and total nitrogen by 8%.
- Eden: total phosphorus fell by 22% and total nitrogen by 17%.
Reductions were larger further upstream. The EA said this suggests that targeting headwaters can deliver proportionally greater benefits.
Future changes in rainfall and temperature reduced the overall efficacy of the measures, with strongly seasonal effects. Buffer strips and cover crops worked better in cooler, wetter months, while in-field wetlands were more effective in summer. Wetlands cut river concentrations of total phosphorus and total nitrogen by up to 3% and 4% respectively in 2060–2080, compared with up to 6% in 2020–2040.
The EA said its confidence in the results is moderated by uncertainties in input data and in the evidence on how well the measures work. The model was validated against observed nutrient concentrations for the recent past. However, a lack of suitable observational data means the modelled effects of the measures themselves cannot be validated.
The EA concluded that effectiveness depends on design, location and management. It said the measures should form part of a range of catchment interventions.
The work was carried out by JBA Consulting and Lancaster University.
What others are reporting
Water Magazine reported the same catchment figures. It noted that the measures act on diffuse agricultural runoff. WaterBriefing also restated the figures and the seasonal findings. Neither outlet carried outside reaction, and The Water Wire found no response from farming bodies, water companies or campaigners.
Background
The EA summary says diffuse nutrient pollution, such as from agriculture, "remains a major barrier" to Good Ecological Status in many English catchments. It adds that knowledge of how nature-based measures perform at catchment scale has been limited. The study was designed to help fill that gap (Environment Agency).
What to watch
- The full report, which should set out how much of each reduction comes from each measure.
- Whether the EA or others build the monitoring needed to validate the modelled effects.
- Reaction from farming organisations, catchment partnerships and water companies.
- Whether the headwater-targeting finding shapes where catchment schemes are placed.
Sources
- 1Environment Agency — Modelling the impact of nature-based solutions on catchment water quality: summary gov.uk ↗
- 2Water Magazine — Nature-based solutions could reduce river nutrient pollution watermagazine.co.uk ↗
- 3WaterBriefing — EA project flags up benefits of nature-based solutions waterbriefing.org ↗
Summarised in our own words. Spotted an error? Tell us — we correct visibly.
Read next
More environment →
EnvironmentSEPA feeds live data from new wave buoys into Scotland's coastal flood forecasts
SEPA is using live data from newly deployed wave buoys to sharpen its coastal flood forecasts, with more deployments planned off the west coast in December, Water Magazine reports.
EnvironmentWelsh Government adds £624,000 to Ffermio Bro farmer-led nature and water scheme
Ministers have added £624,000 to Ffermio Bro after high demand, funding more farmer-led water quality, habitat and natural flood management projects in Wales' designated landscapes, due for delivery by March 2027.
EnvironmentDrought: reservoirs fall to 59.1% as dry-weather incidents pass 2022's total
November rain is at 9% of average, nine reservoirs are exceptionally low and abstraction restrictions have jumped from 336 to 486 in a week, the Environment Agency's latest assessment shows.
The Current · Free
The UK water industry in two minutes, every weekday.
Sourced, independent, no spin. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy notice.

